HC upholds Crime Branch power to probe corruption

‘ACB has no exclusive jurisdiction under J&K Prevention of Corruption Act’

HC upholds eviction from migrant property

Kashmir Impulse Desk

Srinagar, Nov 17

The Jammu and Kashmir High Court has ruled that the Crime Branch has the authority to investigate corruption offences involving public servants, holding that the Anti-Corruption Bureau (ACB) does not have exclusive jurisdiction under the Jammu and Kashmir Prevention of Corruption Act, 2006.

Justice Sanjay Parihar passed the ruling while deciding a petition filed by two doctors challenging the Crime Branch Kashmir’s authority to investigate allegations that they had facilitated the issuance of a false age certificate to secure regularisation and permanent employment for a man in the Public Health Engineering Department.

The petitioners, Dr Gulzar Ahmad and Dr Abdul Lateef, argued that investigations under the Prevention of Corruption Act fell exclusively within the jurisdiction of the Vigilance Organisation, now known as the ACB.

They contended that the Crime Branch could not assume such powers under SRO 202, issued on June 3, 1999.

The Crime Branch opposed the plea, saying the cases were initially registered under provisions of the Ranbir Penal Code relating to cheating, criminal conspiracy and forgery.

It said allegations attracting provisions of the Prevention of Corruption Act emerged only during the investigation and that their subsequent discovery did not invalidate an investigation that had been lawfully initiated.

Rejecting the argument that corruption cases could be investigated only by the ACB, the court said Section 3 of the Prevention of Corruption Act recognised the authority of police officers of the prescribed rank, including those belonging to the regular Police and Crime Branch, to investigate such offences, subject to statutory conditions.

A police officer not below the rank of Deputy Superintendent of Police (DySP) can investigate offences under the Act without prior permission from a Magistrate, the court said.

An officer below that rank must obtain an order from a Magistrate of the First Class before undertaking such an investigation.

Officers of the Vigilance Organisation can also exercise investigative powers subject to the authorisation prescribed under the Act.

The court further held that SRO 202 empowered the Crime Branch to investigate specified categories of offences, including matters relating to the conduct of public servants.

It said an administrative circular governing the allocation of investigative work among agencies could not override statutory powers or restrict jurisdiction granted by law.

The case arose from allegations that the principal accused, G H Bhat, had obtained and used a false age certificate to secure regularisation and permanent employment in the PHE Department.

According to the prosecution, a Medical Board comprising the two petitioners and the then Chief Medical Officer, Dr Abdul Samad Sheikh, assessed Bhat’s age as 32 on December 16, 1999, indicating that he was born around 1967.

However, verification of the service and school records of his son, M S Bhat, showed that the latter was born on February 25, 1966.

The investigating agency alleged that the assessment would make the father younger than his biological son, casting doubt on the authenticity of the age certificate.

The prosecution accused the doctors of abusing their official positions and acting in concert with the beneficiary to facilitate his regularisation and enable him to draw salary and other service benefits from the state exchequer.

On the forgery allegations, the court noted that the certificate had been issued by authorised members of the Medical Board. There was no allegation that the signatures or seals had been forged, that the doctors had impersonated another authority or that the document had been unlawfully altered.

An incorrect statement in a document does not, by itself, amount to the creation of a false document under Section 464 of the Ranbir Penal Code, the court said.

“The falsity of a statement contained in a document is not, by itself, sufficient to constitute forgery,” it observed.

The court held that offences under Sections 467, 468 and 471 of the RPC were not prima facie established against the two doctors because the basic requirement of making a false document had not been met.

However, it distinguished the forgery allegations from those involving cheating, criminal conspiracy and corruption.

The alleged deliberate manipulation of the age assessment to secure financial benefits could attract other penal provisions, it said.

The court held that the allegations of deliberate misrepresentation, alleged collusion between the doctors and the beneficiary, and the resulting financial benefits from the state exchequer provided sufficient prima facie grounds for proceedings under Sections 420 and 120-B of the RPC, read with Section 5(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act.

admin
Written by

admin

More from this author